D.Canarutto - A.Jadczyk - M.Modugno:
Quantum mechanics of a spin particle in a curved spacetime with
absolute time.
Rep. Math. Phys. 36 (1995) 95-140.
Abstract
We present a new covariant approach to the quantum mechanics of a charged
1/2-spin particle in given electromagnetic and gravitational fields. The
background space is assumed to be a curved Galileian spacetime, that is
a curved spacetime with absolute time. This setting is intended both as
a suitable approximation for the case of low speeds and feeble gravitational
fields, and as a guide for eventual extension to fully Einstenian space-time.
Moreover, in the flat spacetime case one completely recovers standard non-relativistic
quantum mechanics.
This work is a generalization of previous work by Jadczyk and Modugno,
where the quantum mechanics of scalar particles was formulated with a similar
approach.
1991 MSC: 15A66, 53A50, 53C07, 81R20, 17B66, 53C15, 58A20, 58F06
Keywords: spin, Galileian spacetime, quantum mechanics on a curved
background, jets, connections.
Introduction
Recently Jadczyk and Modugno have
proposed a new geometric formulation of the quantum mechanics of a scalar
charged particle, with given gravitational and electromagnetic classical
fields, in the framework of a general relativistic Galileian space-time.
In this paper we extend that formulation to the quantum mechanics of a
particle with spin 1/2.
Our work is related to a wide literature on classical and quantum Galileian
theory, starting from E. Cartan. Moreover our theory has evident relations,
but also important differences, with geometric quantization. Our touchstone
is standard quantum mechanic.
Our research is intended as a step toward a covariant formulation of
quantum mechanics in an Einstein general relativistic background. In fact,
such a full goal would demand the solutions of too many problems at the
same time; so, it is worth splitting the research into steps by separating
different kinds of difficulties.
We found that the Galileian general relativistic spacetime provides
a suitable background for a start. Thus our current setting stands in between
a non-relativistic and a fully relativistic formulation of quantum mechanics.
It is mathematically self-consistent, while from the physical point of
view it is intended both as a suitable approximation for the case of low
speeds and feeble gravitational fields, and as a guide for eventual extension
to fully Einstenian spacetime. Actually, the assumptions of a classical
spacetime with absolute time and a Euclidean spacelike metric allows us
to skip (temporarirly) some difficulties related to the Lorentz metric,
but we pay a price for that. Namely, we are forced to consider a weaker
version of the Maxwell and Einstein equations. Nevertheless, what we learn
in this weakened context seems to preserve its interest in view of future
developments. Moreover, in the flat spacetime case one completely recovers
standard non-relativistic quantum mechanics along with new understanding
of known objects.
The mathematical language of the paper is that of the geometry of fibred
manifolds, jets and non-linear connections. We do not deal explicitly with
theoretical group representations: rather we directly obtain physical objects
from our starting structures via functorial methods; of course, the resulting
objects are automatically equivariant with respect to the action of the
groups of automorphisms of the starting structures. The reader who is not
completely acquainted with this language will find, besides intrinsic formulations,
a full coordinate description of all results.
The main points of our theory can be summarized as follows.
First, we sketch the essential features of our background classical
spacetime. Namely, we assume a 4-dimensional spacetime fibred over time
and equipped with a spacelike Euclidean metric, a time preserving linear
connection (the gravitational field) and a 2-form (the electromagnetic
field). We can couple the gravitational and electromagnetic fields into
a unique spacetime connection; this yields a number of 'total' geometric
objects, including a cosymplectic 2-form which will play a key role. We
postulate the closure of this form thus obtaining a link between the above
geometrical structures and the first Maxwell equation; moreover, we postulate
a kind of 'reduced' Einstein and second Maxwell equations expressing the
interaction of the above fields with their matter sources. The cosymplectic
form yields a distinguished Lie algebra of functions, which are called
'quantizable' in view of their role in the theory of quantum operators.
Then we develop the quantum theory starting from the quantum bundle,
defined to be a Hermitian bundle over spacetime; its fibres are either
1-dimensional (scalar case) or 2-dimensional (spin case). On the scalar
quantum bundle we assume a Hermitian connection which, in a sense, is parametrized
by all classical observers, and has some natural properties (it is 'universal'
and its curvature is proportional to the cosymplectic form). In the spin
case we postulate a 'Pauli map', which is an isometry between the bundle
of spacelike vectors and the bundle of Hermitian endomorphisms of the quantum
spin bundle; this, via a natural link with the scalar case, yields a Hermitian
connection on the quantum spin bundle. This is our only primitive quantum
structure; all other objects will be derived from it getting free from
observers through a 'principle of projectability' which is our implementation
of covariance. In particular we obtain a distinguished Lagrangian, which
yields the generalized Pauli equation and conserved quantities. Quantum
operators are obtained in three steps. First, we exhibit a distinguished
algebra of quantum vector fields which preserves the quantum structures,
and study its relation with the algebra of quantizable functions. Then,
we show the natural action of quantum vector fields, as 'almost-quantum
operators', on 'quantum histories' (sections of the quantum bundle). Eventually
we introduce the quantum Hilbert bundle over time and show how to obtain
quantum operators from almost-quantum operators. To this end we have to
eliminate the time derivative; we accomplish this task by a geometric procedure
which uses the quantum Euler-Lagrange operator.
The original features of the paper can be summarized as follows.
i) Time, both in the classical and quantum theory, is not merely a parameter,
but an essential ingredient which deeply affects all involved structures.
Actually we point out - in contrast with an approach usually implicit in
geometric quantization - that spacelike structures do not carry sufficient
physical information for a covariant theory. Accordingly, we deal with
a cosymplectic rather than symplectic form, with a spacetime rather than
vertical (spacelike) connection, and so on. Also, jets are required by
a manifestly covariant formulation; in particular, the jet space of spacetime
plays the role of phase-space and replaces the more standard tangent space.
ii) New connections are introduced and studied. These play a fundamental
and unifying role. In particular, the coupling of the electromagnetic and
gravitational fields is represented by a spacetime connection which works
in classical field theory and mechanics as well as in quantum mechanics;
on the other hand, all quantum structures are derived from the quantum
connection. With regard to the latter, we observe that the notion of 'universality'
of a connection allows us to skip the problem of polarizations, typical
of geometric quantization (we do not need to know the constants of motion
in order to develop the quantum theory). Furthermore, the quantum Euler-Lagrange
operator is interpreted as a connection on the infinite-dimensional Hilbert
bundle (whose definition uses the notion of smoothness introduced by A.
Frölicher).
iii) We obtain a generalized Pauli equation and quantum operators in
the curved case. Actually, a quantization procedure (a way of obtaining
quantum operators from classical observables) was not a primary goal of
our approach; however, as a matter of fact, we get a quantization just
as a free consequence of geometric results arising naturally in our discussion.
We obtained natural algebras of quantizable functions and quantum vector
fields, which yield quantum operators in two steps: first by considering
sections of the quantum bundle over spacetime (almost-quantum operators),
and then sections of the Hilbert bundle over time. In particular we are
able to skip the problems of ordering, and achieve the quantum operator
corresponding to energy. Note also that, differently from other geometrical
approaches to quantum mechanics, no new quantum example is required (all
non-relativistic examples of standard quantum mechanics hold automatically
in our formulation).
iv) By the way, several results are obtained within the covariant approach
to classical mechanics on a curved Galileian background. In particular,
the study of the first and second order spacetime connections and the cosymplectic
form, and a compact formulation of the link between the (non-relativistic)
metric and spacetime connection. Moreover we draw conclusions which are
not common belief: classical mechanics cannot be covariantly formulated
through a Lagrangian or Hamiltonian approach; only an approach based on
a non-linear connection is suitable for that (the Hamiltonian stuff, however,
has an important role in the correspondence principle for quantum mechanics).
v) Finally, we introduce a new mathematically rigorous treatment of
physical quantities, which makes our approach manifestly independent of
the choice of measurement units. By the way, these methods may have also
pedagogical interest.
Acknowledgements. This research has been supported by Italian
MURST (national and local funds), by GNFM of Consiglio Nazionale delle
Ricerche and by the EEC contract N. ERB CHRXCT 930096. Thanks are due to
Andrzej Trautman for stimulating discussion.
|